Your student gets the offer from their dream school… and then the bill arrives.
Don’t let that moment steal the joy. Build cost into your college list from the very beginning, right alongside fit, majors, and location. You may already have a budget in mind, but figuring out what a specific college will actually cost takes some research.
Below are ways you can start to figure out your actual cost along with the questions families ask us most often about paying for college.
Part One: How do I estimate what I will have to pay?
The Short Version
Start with the published price that’s on the website. Plan on about $3,000 more per year for costs colleges don’t list (travel, Greek life fees, etc.)
Run each college’s Net Price Calculator while you build the list, not after acceptances arrive.
File the FAFSA senior fall, plus the CSS Profile if a college requires it, even if you expect to pay full price.
Compare award letters carefully and don’t be afraid to ask a college to reconsider.
Before You Apply: “How much will we actually pay?”
Two numbers drive everything:
Cost of Attendance (COA): the full price of one year at a college.
Student Aid Index (SAI): a number calculated from the FAFSA that estimates what your family can contribute.
The Formula used to determine Financial Need
Cost of Attendance − Student Aid Index = Financial Need
Financial need is the gap a college may help fill with need-based aid. What you actually pay, often called your net price, is the Cost of Attendance minus any grants and scholarships you receive. Loans lower what you pay up front, but they still have to be repaid.
Part Two: Question and Answers
Cost of Attendance
Q: Colleges post their total costs on their websites. Will we pay more than that?
Usually, yes. We advise adding about $3,000 to whatever amount is published.
Costs often NOT included in published “Total Costs”
Tuition
Fees
Books and supplies
On-campus room and board Off-campus housing and food
Personal expenses
Travel (rideshares, gas, airfare)
Sorority or fraternity dues
Helpful resource: Average Annual Costs Per School (College Scorecard). Note that for public colleges, this shows in-state costs only.
Student Aid Index
Q: How do colleges decide what we’re able to pay?
They use your Student Aid Index (SAI), which comes from the FAFSA. The FAFSA pulls your federal tax return from two years before your student starts college, along with other factors, to make its estimate.
Try it yourself for a rough estimate:
Or search “Net Price Calculator” plus the college’s name
Before You Sit Down with a Net Price Calculator, Make sure to have:
Your tax return from two years before your student starts college
Your student’s current high school GPA
SAT or ACT scores, if available
About 45 minutes. Make it an “appointment” with your student and do the research together. Be ready to answer questions about your income.
Senior Fall: “What do we need to file? What do we need to do to be considered for financial aid?”
Many colleges consider students for academic (“merit”) scholarships automatically when they apply. For need-based aid and federal loans, colleges use one or both of these applications:
1. Federal Application for Student Federal Aid (FASFA)
Decides: federal aid, state aid, college grants and scholarships
Opens: Fall of senior year (around Oct. 1)
Costs: Free (some colleges charge a fee, but waivers exist)
2. College Scholarship Service Profile (CSS Profile) - only used by private colleges
Both use your tax return from two years before your student graduates high school. Example: the Class of 2027 will report 2025 income.
Federal student loan limits: a dependent undergraduate can borrow up to $31,000 total over four years, and no more than $23,000 of that can be subsidized.
Q: Our SAI says we’ll be expected to pay the full cost. Why bother filing the FAFSA?
There are several good reasons:
It protects you in later years. If you rely on income to pay for college and that income changes, you’ll want to already be in the college’s system. Some colleges limit need-based aid in later years for families who didn’t apply the first year.
It can help your student build credit. Federal student loans are in the student’s name, so repaying them helps establish a good credit history.
It gives your student a stake. If you want your student to contribute to their own education, repaying this loan is one way to do it.
It matters if you’ll have more than one child in college. The FAFSA no longer factors in siblings in college, but many CSS Profile colleges still do.
Graduate school may be in the picture. If so, you’re in this for the long haul.
Q: Won’t it help my student get admitted if we can pay full price?
Not as much as many families think. A “need-aware” college does consider a student’s ability to pay, but that will not outweigh academics and the rest of the application. Some people say being able to pay helps at private colleges, but this has not been proven or documented.
After Acceptance: “We’ve been accepted! Now what?”
The Financial Aid Award Package
Q: What funding might my student receive to offset the costs?
If you submitted the FAFSA (and CSS Profile, if required) by the college’s deadline, you’ll receive a financial aid award letter, usually two weeks to two months after your student is accepted. It may include: Grants, Scholarships, and Federal Loans. The only thing you have to pay back are loans.
Q: How are scholarships awarded?
Merit awards from colleges are usually based on GPA, academic performance, and SAT/ACT scores rather than financial need. Colleges use them to attract students they want.
College-Based Competitive Scholarships: Application Based - Students have to complete an application once they apply.
Outside Scholarships based on national and community organizations: These are usually advertised online or from you students’ high school counselor.
Keep in mind:
Many scholarships require the student to maintain a certain GPA.
Some college scholarships require a separate application with its own deadline.
Outside organizations, such as the Rotary Club, also offer scholarships. Your high school counselor is the best person to help you vet these lists.
Q: What will our return on investment be?
Return on investment depends more on the major than on the college. These resources show data on post-graduation earnings:
Ranking 4,600 Colleges by ROI (Georgetown, 2025)
The U.S. Colleges with the Highest ROI (Poets&Quants)
The College Scorecard
The KEY Takeaways
College is a long-term investment. The “we’ll figure it out” approach can put your retirement savings and income at risk.
Know your number early. Decide what you’re willing to pay and estimate each college’s cost as you build the list.
Talk with your student about what you can and are willing to pay for their college experience.
Take your time with award letters. Weigh your options and don’t be afraid to negotiate. After all, colleges are businesses.
Don’t be surprised by your student’s college award letter! Take our advice and enjoy your students’ college acceptances. You have all earned this special moment!
Clear and Concise Study Guide: How to Analyze Primary Sources
Purpose
Identify the main argument or point of view expressed in the source.
Determine the source’s historical context and intended audience.
Evaluate the source’s credibility, perspective, and usefulness for research.
Steps to Analyze a Primary Source
Observe (What do you see?)
Note the type of source (letter, diary, speech, photograph, government document, artifact).
Record explicit details: date, author/creator, place of creation, and any visible labels or marks.
Describe content and form: language, tone, length, visual elements, physical condition.
Contextualize (When and why was it created?)
Place the source in its historical timeframe. Identify relevant events, social conditions, or cultural movements underway at that time.
Ask why the source was created: to inform, persuade, record, commemorate, instruct, or entertain.
Identify the intended audience and how audience expectations shaped the content.
Analyze Perspective and Purpose (Who produced it, and with what motive?)
Consider the creator’s background: social status, occupation, political affiliations, gender, race, and personal interests.
Detect bias, omissions, or emphasis. Ask what the creator assumes the audience already knows.
Determine purpose: Is the source meant to persuade, justify actions, recruit support, document events, or express personal feelings?
Corroborate and Compare (How does it fit with other evidence?)
Compare this source with other primary and secondary sources on the same topic.
Look for agreements and contradictions. Use multiple sources to build a fuller, more reliable picture.
Consider whether this source represents a common perspective or an exception.
Evaluate Reliability and Usefulness
Assess accuracy: Are details specific and verifiable? Does the creator have direct knowledge or rely on hearsay?
Consider limitations: Are facts missing, exaggerated, or shaped by rhetorical goals?
Decide how the source can be used in research: as direct evidence, illustrative material, or a perspective to be balanced with others.
Key Questions to Ask
Who created this source, and when?
What is the author’s main message?
For whom was it intended?
What is left out or assumed?
How might the author’s position affect the content?
How does this source compare with others from the same period?
Quick Checklist for Students
Cite the source with full details (author, title, date, repository).
Summarize the content in one sentence.
State the likely purpose and audience.
Note at least two ways the source is biased or limited.
Identify one corroborating and one contradictory source (if available).
Explain in 2–3 sentences how this source contributes to your research question or thesis.
Example Application (brief) Source: Excerpt of a 1918 letter from a factory worker complaining about long hours.
Observe: Handwritten, dated June 1918, signed by “E. Martinez,” mentions 12-hour shifts.
Contextualize: Produced during World War I when industrial output increased and labor shortages occurred.
Perspective/Purpose: Worker’s firsthand account to document conditions or appeal for help; likely intended for a union organizer or local newspaper.
Corroborate: Compare with factory records, contemporary newspaper reports, and union minutes.
Evaluate: Useful as direct evidence of working conditions but limited by single-person perspective and potential exaggeration.
Tips for Success
Take careful notes and record exact quotes to support your interpretations.
Keep context research focused: political, economic, social, and cultural factors usually matter.
Distinguish clearly between what the source says and your interpretation of why it says it.
Use primary sources to generate questions as well as answers.
Use this guide as a framework when approaching any primary source. Apply the same steps to visual and material culture, adjusting questions to address medium-specific elements (composition, symbolism, production techniques).